Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Frank Sterle Jr.'s avatar

Christ was viciously murdered largely because he did not in the least behave in accordance with corrupted human conduct and expectation—and in particular because he was nowhere near being the angry and sometimes even bloodthirsty behemoth so many theists seemingly wanted or needed their Creator and savior to be and therefore believed he’d have to be.

Christ’s nature and teachings even left John the Baptist, who believed in him as the savior, bewildered by his apparently contradictory version of the Hebraic messiah, with which John had been raised. Perhaps most perplexing was the Biblical Jesus’ revolutionary teaching of non-violently offering the other cheek as the proper response to being physically assaulted by one’s enemy. The Biblical Jesus also most profoundly washed his disciples’ feet, the act clearly revealing that he took corporeal form to serve.

Perhaps some ‘Christians’ even find inconvenient, if not plainly annoying, trying to reconcile the conspicuous inconsistency in the fundamental nature of the New Testament’s Jesus with the wrathful, vengeful and even jealous nature of the Old Testament’s God. But for many of us, Godly greatness need not be defined as the ability to destroy and harshly punish, as opposed to the willingness and compacity for compassionate forgiveness, non-violence and humility.

... Morally speaking, the citizenry collectively deserve far better than always having either the usual callous establishment conservative or neo/faux liberal government. But, regardless of who’s elected prime minister or president , we in the Far West live in a virtual corpocracy. An insidiously covert rule by way of potently manipulative/persuasive corporate and big-monied lobbyists.

The more they make, all the more they want — nay, need! — to make next quarterly. It’s never enough, yet the corporate news-media, which make up virtually all of Western mainstream news media, will implicitly or explicitly celebrate their successful greed [a.k.a. ‘stock market gains’].

A few social/labor uprisings or revolutions notwithstanding, it seems the superfluously rich and powerful have always had the police and military ready to foremost protect their big-money/-power interests, even over the basic needs of the masses, to the very end.

Even in modern (supposed) democracies, the police and military can, and perhaps would, claim—using euphemistic or political terminology, of course—they have/had to bust heads to maintain law and order as a priority during major demonstrations, especially those against economic injustices. Indirectly supported by a complacent, if not compliant, corporate news-media, which is virtually all mainstream news-media, the absurdly unjust inequities/inequalities can persist.

Perhaps there were/are lessons learned from those successful social/labor uprisings, with the clarity of hindsight, by more-contemporary big power/money interests in order to avoid any repeat of such great wealth/power losses (a figurative How to Hinder Progressive Revolutions 101, maybe)?

Tim Byers's avatar

Wes, thank you for this thoughtful and gracious article. I deeply appreciate your commitment to following Jesus’ teachings on nonviolence and your respectful tone toward those who serve or have served in the military and law enforcement.

That said, I’m not fully persuaded that Scripture requires Christians to abstain from all roles involving state authority or the use of force. One example that gives me pause is the Philippian jailer in Acts 16. After his dramatic conversion, he is baptized that same night, yet there’s no indication that Paul instructed him to resign his post, even though his duties included force and the use of a sword. If being a jailer was inherently incompatible with following Christ, wouldn’t Paul have likely told him before baptizing him as part of “counting the cost” of serving Christ?

We see a similar example in Luke 3:14, where John the Baptist instructs soldiers not to leave the military, but to act with integrity: “Do not extort money from anyone by threats or by false accusation, and be content with your wages.” Rather than condemning their occupation, he calls them to be righteous within it.

Also, in Romans 13:4, Paul refers to civil authorities as “God’s servant” who carries out justice. While Christians are personally called to non-retaliation (Romans 12), Paul does not prohibit participation in government roles. In fact, Erastus, a Christian brother that Paul mentions in Romans 16:23, served as a city treasurer. This is evidence that early Christians could hold civic office.

One further concern I have is that your position seems to imply that when Paul describes governing officials as “God’s servants” in Romans 13, they must necessarily be non-Christians, since you believe Christians are to refrain from all use of coercive authority. That raises a difficult question: why would God entrust such serious moral responsibility to unbelievers but exclude his own people from serving conscientiously in those roles? If Christians are shaped by Jesus’ love, mercy, and humility, wouldn’t those be the very qualities we’d want in those entrusted with justice and public order?

I respect your desire to faithfully live out Jesus’ call to peace. At the same time, let's be careful not to infer more than the text actually teaches. I believe there is room for Christians to serve conscientiously in public roles that restrain evil and uphold justice as “God’s servants” so long as they do so with humility, compassion, and a clear conscience before God.

7 more comments...

Ready for more?