Stop Dismissing Scripture with, “That’s Just Your Interpretation!”

Wes  —  December 2, 2015
  • Sumo

Occasionally I will have a conversation, or overhear a conversation, where a person is told what the Bible says on a certain subject, but they quickly respond, “Well, that’s just your interpretation!” As if that statement settled the matter once and for all. They seem to believe everyone has a right to their own interpretation of Scripture and one interpretation is just as valid as another. Here are a few thoughts on that line of reasoning.

your interpretation

Understanding Some Important Words

There are some words we use all the time and we just assume people understand what they mean, but perhaps it would be good to take a moment to define some important terms:

Translation – The 66 books of the Bible were written in three different languages (Hebrew, Aramaic, and Greek). Therefore, in order for English-speakers to read them today, they must be translated into English. There are many reliable English translations of the Bible and they have been translated from the original languages by groups of experts and scholars who have devoted their lives to understanding these languages. The translators primary concern is: What does the text say?

Interpretation – The books of the Bible were not only written in different languages, they were written thousands of years ago in completely different cultures from our own. So even when a book has been translated to English, it can still be difficult for people today to understand what the author was talking about. We ALL must interpret Scripture, but this simply means we must must ask the question: What does the text mean? 

Application – When the biblical text has been translated into English and we have done the hard work to understand what the text means, then we must apply it to our own lives. We must ask the question: What difference should the text make in my life?

Only One Right Interpretation

We need to understand an important principle, a biblical text only has only one right interpretation. In other words, it only means one thing. The idea that everyone is entitled to their own interpretation and every interpretation is just as valid as another, is completely ridiculous.

If the person who hears or reads a statement can decide for himself what the statement means, and there is not one right meaning, then attempting to communicate with each other becomes pointless. Imagine a policeman pulling a driver over for failing to stop at a stop sign. The policeman says, “Sir, did you see that stop sign?” The driver responds, “Yes sir, I did.” Confused, the officer says, “Don’t you understand that means you have to stop?” And the driver smiles and says, “Well, that’s your interpretation.”

The meaning of a particular passage might be difficult to understand; but rest assured, it only has one correct interpretation. The Bible is not some mystical book that changes meanings depending on who is reading it. It doesn’t mean different things to different people. When the prophet or apostle penned those particular words to the original audience, he meant something. Our job is to figure out, what did he mean by that? 

Interpretation Requires Hard Work

Understanding what a passage of Scripture means can be difficult. As I said earlier, the books of the Bible were written by men living in an entirely different culture. On top of that, different books of the Bible must be interpreted differently. For instance, the book of Psalms is a book of poetry and you can’t interpret poetry the same way you interpret historical narratives like the book of Joshua.

If we want to know the Truth, we must do the hard work of interpretation. We must ask questions like:

  • Who wrote this book?
  • To whom did he write it?
  • When did he write it?
  • What literature style was he using?
  • What was the primary purpose of this book?

The more we understand the answers to these questions, the better conclusions we will reach about the correct meaning of Scripture. And this is NOT an impossible task. God wants His people to understand what Scripture means. The Bible was written to be timeless. It was written to be read for centuries. It was written to be understood.

Several Possible Meanings

I will readily admit there are some difficult passages of Scripture to interpret (not nearly as many as some people would have you believe). These passages have various possible meanings. In other words, scholars and theologians disagree on what the passage means and they have come up with several different possible interpretations. But at the end of the day, there is only one right interpretation and all the other interpretations are wrong.

Let’s Stop Being Lazy and/or Disobedient

When a brother in Christ admonishes me, saying, “Scripture says you’re wrong for what you’re doing,” and I respond with, “Well, that’s just your interpretation,” at the very least I am being lazy and at the worst I’m being disobedient to God.

It could be the person is wrong in his interpretation. In that case, we need to sit down together and figure out the correct interpretation of the text and how it applies to the lives of Christians today. If he is wrong in his interpretation and I know he is wrong, it isn’t loving or kind for me to leave him with the impression that it’s alright for him to continue on with a wrong interpretation; as if we are all entitled to different interpretations.

But it could also be that his interpretation is correct. If so, I need to yield my life to God’s will. It’s easy to just dismiss something with, “That’s not how I interpret that passage,” but it’s easy because it is often disobedience. Disobedience is easy.

The Bottom Line

Just because you don’t like what a passage of Scripture means, doesn’t mean you can just interpret a different way. If you would be a disciple of Christ, you must accept some difficult and challenging truths as revealed in Scripture.

I love you and God loves you,

Wes McAdams